Skip to main content

Studentoid: The new creature in the classroom


In our quest to assess the intelligence of a student, through mechanisms like exams, classroom participation, quizs, and so on; we often forget to distinguish between a student and a ‘studentoid’!


Heard of the humanoid? A humanoid is a thing in the guise of a being that has an appearance resembling a human being without really being one (Oxford English Dictionary Online, n.d.). For example, a smart phone! It can perform many intelligent functions like a human being, but it's not a human being. Rather, it has some characteristics that intrinsically are humanly.


Similarly, a ‘studentoid’ is something, not someone, who attempts to look like a student, comes to the classroom, participates in the classroom activities like hearing the lectures and taking quizzes but not necessarily being endowed with all the attributes a student.


In the view of the above, it is important to mention that a student should be interested in grades and getting a job, but a defining trait of a student is to take “an interest in a particular subject” (Oxford English Dictionary Online, n.d.).


Interest is “being engaged, engrossed, or entirely taken up with” an activity, object, or topic (Dewey, 2009[1913]: 17). It is studied as a part of: (a) “emotional experience, curiosity, and momentary motivation;” and (b) “personality, individual differences, and people’s idiosyncratic hobbies, goals, and avocations” (Silvia, 2006: 4). Hence, interest can be segregated as: emotional interest and developed interest; what someone is born with in the case of the former and what s/he grooms her/his inclinations in the case of the latter. Hence, the holistic facet of someone’s interest is the combination of the inclinations that s/he is intrinsically good at and what s/he has acquired through studying theories and experiencing (student) life in general.


Now, how many teachers in the MBA level assess a student based on the Holland Code, one of the highly reliable and valid tests to know what a person should ideally become professionally? Similarly, how many of them assess a student based on his theoretical abilities along with practical competencies? And, from a common sense angle, how many teachers note the active listening ability of a student while assessing for classroom performance? I’m afraid, not many!

Teacher or teacheroid (a discussion for another time)!

To conclude, in line with all that looks like a human isn’t necessarily human, but some could be a humanoid; all that looks like a student may not be a student but may be a ’studentoid’.


References

Dewey, J. 2009[1913]. Interest and effort in education. Boston, MA: Houghton Mifflin.

Oxford English Dictionary Online (n.d.). Humanoid. Retrieved from https://www.oed.com/public/learning/loginpage

Oxford English Dictionary Online (n.d.). Student. Retrieved from https://www.oed.com/public/learning/loginpage

Silvia, P. J. 2001. Interest and interests: The psychology of constructive capriciousness. Review of General Psychology, 5: 270-290.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

In Search of the Motherly Manager: Unlocking the KADAMBINI code

In Search of the Motherly Manager: Unlocking the KADAMBINI code " All that I am, or hope to be, I owe to my angel mother. " - Abraham Lincoln (the 16th President of the United States of America) " Achieving the highest possible return on human capital must be every manager's goal ." - Brian Tracy (Canadian-American motivational public speaker and self-development author) 'M' for Mother, 'M' for Manager! Mother! She conceptualizes us during her marital bliss, being unaware of who we are or will become. She bears us in our embryonic state, compromising with many of her normal ways of living. She gives birth to us, being in unbearable pain. She grooms us, sacrificing much of her comforts. She wipes our tears away, even if she's chocking inside. She attends us when we are sick and weak, spending sleepless nights. She ties our shoelaces, enduring back pain at times. She helps us in our homework, forgetting her favorite soap ope...
2 comments
Read more

Apathy toward business ethics! Are we confused between the message and the messenger?

Apathy toward business ethics! Are we confused between the message and the messenger? “ Ethics is knowing the difference between what you have a right to do and what is right to do .” — Potter Stewart (Associate Justice of the United States Supreme Court, serving from 1958 to 1981) While teaching the MBA Oath 1  (Nohria & Khurana, 2008), I mentioned Prof. Nitin Nohria, the first Asian Dean of the Harvard Business School, as one of the pioneers of teaching business ethics and discussed what MBA Oath referred, why it should be administered, and how to create ethical conduct in leaders and managers. Many of the students were not convinced. One of the reason could be the composition of the class (nearly 85-90 percent of the students have engineering background); they mostly believe that the crux of scientific causality is (traditional) positivism 2  and many aspects of ethics are based on antipositivism 3  and/or constructionism 4  paradigms. Hence, wh...
1 comment
Read more

Apathy toward business ethics! Are we confused between the message and the messenger?

While teaching the MBA Oath (Nohria & Khurana, 2008), I mentioned Prof. Nitin Nohria, the first Asian Dean of the Harvard Business School, as one of the pioneers of teaching business ethics and discussed what MBA Oath refers to, why it should be administered, and how could create ethical conduct in leaders and managers. Many of the students were not convinced. One of the reason could be due to the composition of the class (nearly 85-90 percent of the students have engineering background); they mostly believe that the crux of scientific causality is (traditional) positivism and many aspects of ethics are based on anti-positivist and constructionism paradigms. Hence, when it comes to business ethics, most of my students are of the opinion that it does not deserve a space in the management science curricula nor in manager practitioners’ field.      In the middle of the classroom discussion, one of the students quipped, “How can he [Prof. Nohria] talk about ethics [M...
Post a Comment
Read more