Skip to main content

Making business ethics a core course in B-schools

In many B-schools, business ethics (BE) is being introduced as a core course. One needs to analyse the demand side and supply side to find its true relevance for managers.

The demand side practitioners emphasize on bottom-line. It's not that they don't prefer ethical decision-making but they just don't know whether the other person is ethical or not. Consequently, the demand side mostly tries to give lip-service to it to cut cost and remain a going concern. The supply side mainly comprises of consultants and B-school faculties who generally try to operationalise BE as CSR or a means to mitigate various (extra) costs like government regulations/interventions, hue and cry by civil society activists, etc., in the events of unethical business practices.

Furthermore, who head the CSR projects in organizations; well, they are mostly the superstars with expertise in core functional areas like marketing, finance, and so on. Hence, the bottomline thinking slowly but steadfastly creeps into the CSR, (sic) BE, realm; and the same vicious cycle of profiteering at all cost (and unethical modus operandi) takes the full circle. And, who are teaching BE in B-schools? We know that CSR is in great demand in the market primarily for window-dressing and cost-cutting purposes. The industy captains also are showing increasing interest in it mainly for bottom-line objectives. And, CSR is being taught in the name of BE in B-schools. Hence, it is unsurprising that one witnesses a rate race among faculties to teach it because: 1. to become the darlings of the market players and getting new consulting projects in return, and 2. to embelish their CV and get more of such projects. And most of them do not have any training nor education in ethics! All they have is a motivation to teach BE; motivation without expertise!! Isn't it like intending to drive downtown to have coffee without knowing if there's fuel in the car!!!

In the process, a subject which needs to be practiced and taught with diligence ends up being abused thoroughly. Period! As you can see the demand and supply sides of BE is just tantamount to an obsession for the sake of looking fashionable and up-to-date. Here, one mustn't forget that being ethical is fundamentally human, not entrepreneurial; BE too is. But, how many humans do we encounter in the workplace nowadays?

Till demand side is bereft of humans and supply side continues to create humanoids (the neoclassical version of managers), BE will remain an oxymoron. A situation wherein an obsolete subject will be made a core course!

Quoting Peter Drucker, “When a subject becomes totally obsolete we make it a required course.”

Doesn't Drucker's words resonate with the current state of BE as a core course in B-schools? :)

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The present state of the Corporate and two fundamental issues

The present state of the Corporate and two fundamental issues Yesterday Kingfisher went off the sky, today it's the turn of Jet, and tomorrow (God forbid) another! Who's at fault? Employees? Company decision-makers? Shareholders? Governments? And the list goes on. I ain't here to find where the fault lies; there're many who're already doing it. Rather, I'm rekindling two issues that have been ignored by practitioners and academics alike, since quite some time. As management is neither a science nor an art, but a practice; I'll discuss the practitioners' issue first. So, here's the first one. It pertains to the practitioners. It hovers around the classic question posed by Socrates in the fourth century BC: How 'one' should live? The question isn't how I should live? Or, how you should live? But, how 'one' should live? The 'one' that Socrates mentioned is the human, i.e., homo sapiens. Homo sapiens isn'...
Post a Comment
Read more

Studentoid: The new creature in the classroom

In our quest to assess the intelligence of a student, through mechanisms like exams, classroom participation, quizs, and so on; we often forget to distinguish between a student and a ‘studentoid’! Heard of the humanoid? A humanoid is a thing in the guise of a being that has an appearance resembling a human being without really being one (Oxford English Dictionary Online, n.d.). For example, a smart phone! It can perform many intelligent functions like a human being, but it's not a human being. Rather, it has some characteristics that intrinsically are humanly. Similarly, a ‘studentoid’ is something, not someone, who attempts to look like a student, comes to the classroom, participates in the classroom activities like hearing the lectures and taking quizzes but not necessarily being endowed with all the attributes a student. In the view of the above, it is important to mention that a student should be interested in grades and getting a job, but a defining trait ...
Post a Comment
Read more

Business ethics demand versus supply and more

Business ethics demand versus supply and B-schools Indian banking industry at present is in the midst of controversies. The recent high profile scandals notably PNB fraud involving the Gitanjali Group and ICICI bad loans involving Videocon, have created tremors across corporate corridors, e.g., change in leadership in both the banks. It seems business ethics is once again on the Board Room agenda, as always at the time of crisis. However, these instances of surface surfing unfortunately are far from the deeper realities. In 2012, in an article entitled: Do Business Schools Incubate Criminals? Luigi G. Zingales, a finance professor at the University of Chicago, had argued that the scandals that expose corruption and deception in business were not merely the doing of isolated crooks; rather they were the result of an amoral culture that business-schools helped foster. He emphasized that the cleansing should start from B-school classrooms, which is a herculean task consideri...
Post a Comment
Read more